Episode 2 begins at the coupled guys' resort, Captain Morgan's Retreat (CMR). Host Mark meets Kaya, Andy, Taheed and Billy for breakfast and asks what happened after they said goodbye to their girlfriends. Flashbacks reveal escapades from the night before as the single ladies pursue the guys, especially Billy. Mark wonders if the men are experiencing butterflies. The guys reveal that they have good reason to be nervous - they've heard that there are a few ""crocodiles"" among the single women who will stop at nothing to get their man.

Later that morning, Mandy, Ytossie, Shannon and Valerie meet Mark at Mata Chica. Much like their partners, the women are experiencing some first date butterflies. Shannon, in particular, is so nervous that she can't eat breakfast. Mark tells the women that their blind dates (four single guys) will be coming to pick them up at their cabanas shortly.

The coupled men and women are swept away by their blind dates, and each date begins a day filled with exciteme