This episode opens on Day 8, late at night, thirty minutes after the last bonfire. The women return to the water taxi in turmoil. Mandy is completely upset by the video clips, which have shown the coupled guys bashing her for the body shot incident, and Billy performing a pseudo striptease for the single girls. Her anxiety gets Valerie's wheels spinning about what footage of her Kaya might have seen -if Kaya has seen her Jacuzzi jump, he might retaliate. Shannon cautioned ""what you learn out of context is only going to destroy you."" Mandy fears she is about to throw away a year and a half of an amazing relationship with Billy.

Returning to Captain Morgan's Retreat, Billy, Kaya, and Andy are indeed concerned about the after-hours activities at their partners' resort. Kaya is still wondering about the hot tub sequences and Andy speculates that it probably ""wasn't just Mr. Massage Rub a Dub Dub therapy guy doing that towel thing."" Billy and Kaya agree that all the single guys did that. Wh