When the gang comes to Annie's rescue after she finds a mouse in her apartment, they all end up playing a late night game of truth or dare. During the game, Annie accepts a challenge to ask a man out on a date, rather than identify the person about whom she had a sexual dream.

When Annie fails miserably at the dating game, the rest of the group grapples with other dares: Elliot overcomes his shyness by walking through a bar in his brief, briefs.

Roger overcomes his homophobia by getting a senual massage from another man, and Didi faces her fear of death by attending a stranger's funeral.