Five guys from rival Douglas High arrive on the island, including Nikol's (The Good Girl) senior year boyfriend. Tempers and egos heat up during a Cardinal Gibbons vs Douglas High football game that lands Jim (The Jock) in the hospital with a head injury and Nikol at his side. Jen (The Predator) backstabs Nikki (The Cheerleader) when they both find themselves attracted to the same Douglas hunk. Gianni (The Basketball Star) and Loretta (The Dream Girl) share another romantic evening and worry about Gianni's upcoming return to Italy.