After Livvie threatens to reveal to the whole town that Caleb's, Caleb dares her to do it. She goes to Lucy and warns her, then they both arrive at the hospital costume party to warn everyone else about Caleb. However, Livvie is forced to explain to everyone how Caleb tricked her into posing as Anne Marie and Christina, kidnapping Daniel and bringing Valerie to town. Everyone turns their rage towards Livvie and they lock her up in a psychiatric ward. Livvie then awakens and realizes she's had a nightmare, courtesy of Caleb. Caleb seems confident that he's convinced Livvie to do his bidding.