After seeing the photo of Ian and Lucy in bed, Eve realizes Kevin already knows about their affair. Vowing to make Ian pay, Eve steals truth serum from the hospital, just as Ian tells Lucy he feels he and Eve are close to reconciling. After Jack escapes from the hospital, Alison finds him in the woods and he tells her he encountered pure evil. Livvie subtely clues in Valerie that Jamal is Hope's biological father, then Valerie confronts Jamal, who admits it's true. Val presses him to meet with the Hartmans. Lucy goes to the catacombs ready to do battle with Caleb, but is intercepted by an overprotective James.