Gail comes to the lighthouse with questions for Livvie about the ""witchcraft"" she's witnessed. At the barn, Kevin cautions Alison that her candles are much more potent than she knows. Karen pulls a startled Ricky into a kiss as he leans over the couch to check on his sleeping guest. Kevin asks Alison to close down her shop until he can have the candles analyzed. Recalling how her ancestor was persecuted and killed, Alison wonders if she is destined to suffer the same fate. Livvie angrily accuses Gail and Lucy of trying to trick her into admitting that she's as crazy as her mother. Realizing that Karen has mistaken him for Frank, Ricky pulls back from her embrace. Frank arrives and launches into an explanation for his bizarre behavior but quickly falls under the spell of the lit candle once again. Alison agrees to let Kevin test her inventory to prove that Rebecca's recipes are harmless. Ricky bodily ejects Frank from his apartment, then reminds a heartbroken Karen that she's better off