While dining with Elizabeth and Stephen, Rafe and Alison grill Stephen about his past, but he remains evasive. Convinced he's Caleb, Rafe steals Stephen's wallet to learn more about him. Ian takes Tess to his loft and she sees pics of Eve, then says she can't heal Ian's broken heart. Jack vows to protect Tess from Livvie, who realizes he's in love with Tess. After Livvie tells him about her encounter with Caleb, Jack allows Livvie to stay with him, then remembers being bitten by Caleb. Stephen takes Elizabeth back to her hotel room where they get passionate. He vows to deal with Rafe the slayer in his own way.