Tess tells a disbelieving Jack she and Livvie are the same and worries he'll stop loving her when he finds out why. Tess doesn't tell Jack she had another vision of Livvie. With Livvie in the closet, Stephen almost makes love to Elizabeth until a phone call interrupts them. Stephen catches Livvie in the closet and she's jealous he almost made love to Elizabeth in front of her. He almost convinces her he's not Caleb but slips by calling her Olivia. Rafe enters Alison's dream to make her see Stephen is Caleb. In the dream, Stephen turns into a vampire and bites Ali. Meanwhile, Elizabeth's unable to wake Ali from her dream.