Caleb takes Tess on a carriage ride and feels attracted to her kindness but reminds himself he wants Livvie. Tess thanks him for the date, then goes home to Jack. After making love, Ian doesn't feel pain and credits Lucy for temporarily curing him. When Gail's worried about Lucy, Kevin shows up at the cabin to check on her. Lucy tries to hide her tryst with Ian, who exposes it to Kevin. After Elizabeth kills Joshua to protect Alison, Ali helps her get rid of the body and urges her mom to leave Caleb. When Joshua doesn't answer Caleb's phone call, Caleb shows up unexpectedly just as Ali and Elizabeth are hiding the body.